Does your human know when to take over?

A close view of a tennis umpire, showing his face, hands and controls, with the Brightbeam logo.

At Wimbledon last year, the umpire in the chair watched a ball land well long. Then he picked up the phone.

Anyone deciding what their own ‘human in the loop’ is for should know why.

It was the first summer without line judges. Players had appealed to the cameras for 18 years, and often proved the line judge wrong. So in 2025, the club gave the cameras every line, and a recorded voice now shouts ‘out’.

But it kept the umpire.

And at four games all on Centre Court, the voice said nothing. In tennis, no call means the ball was in.

An operator had switched the tracking off on that side by mistake, for one game. And nobody had told the umpire the machine was off, or that the call was now his.

So instead of calling it, he phoned for advice, and the point was replayed. Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova went on to lose the game. ‘That’s why he’s there sitting on the chair,’ she said.

The club didn’t bring the line judges back. It took away the switch.

Two days later, on another court, the system shouted ‘fault’ mid-rally. A ball kid crossing the net had confused it. This time it was wrong out loud, and the umpire, a different one, had the point replayed without needing to be told.

Most of us don’t work on grass. But AI agents are starting to make the line calls in plenty of offices: matching invoices, sorting claims, checking contracts against policy.

And Wimbledon’s split is a good one to copy. Give agents the calls they make more reliably than people, and keep experts for the judgements agents don’t make reliably yet.

What went wrong on Centre Court was the handover. An agent that’s stopped flagging things looks just like one with nothing to flag. An empty review queue can mean all’s well, or that nobody’s checking.

Wimbledon’s response was to take away the switch. But that’s not always an option.

So when your agents get something wrong, do they do it out loud? And does the person in your chair know which calls are theirs?

Related

More from Brightbeam

So tell us what you’re working on.

Get in touch